The Old Witch Down the Block
An Old Halloween Tale We Heard in the 1950’s
Back in the 1950’s, there was an old Halloween story that some of us kids heard about the witch who lived down the block. Like so many stories passed from one kid to another, nobody seemed to know exactly where it started or how much of it was true. But when you were young and Halloween was getting close, it certainly sounded real.
The story was about an old woman who lived by herself in a dark house down the block. The neighborhood children called her the old witch. They whispered about her at school, talked about her while sitting on the stoop, and dared one another to walk past her house after the sun went down.
As Halloween approached, the story always seemed to get a little scarier.
And on Halloween night, when the leaves were blowing along the sidewalk and the streetlights were glowing through the bare branches, every kid remembered the same warning:
“Don’t go near the old witch’s house down the block.”
It was Halloween night in 1957, and everybody in the neighborhood knew about the old witch who lived in the dark house down the block.
At least, we thought she was a witch.
Nobody really knew her name. She was an elderly woman who lived alone in an old two-story house surrounded by tall trees. During the day it didn’t look especially frightening, but on Halloween night, with the wind blowing through the bare branches and dry leaves tumbling across the sidewalk, it was a different story.
We were about twelve years old that Halloween, and after supper we put on our homemade costumes. There were ghosts made from old sheets, cowboys, hobos, pirates and witches. We grabbed our pillowcases and paper bags and headed outside.
“Be home by eight!” Mom called from the doorway.
We joined the other neighborhood kids and started making our rounds.
House after house we shouted, “Trick or treat!”
Candy bars, Tootsie Rolls, apples, popcorn balls and homemade cookies disappeared into our bags. Before long, our pillowcases were getting heavy.
Then someone said the words everybody had been avoiding.
“Are we going to the old witch’s house?”
Suddenly nobody was quite so brave.
“I heard she turns kids into black cats,” Tommy whispered.
“That’s baloney.”
“Then you knock on her door.”
We stood beneath the streetlight looking down the block.
There it was.
The old house.
Of course, telling a bunch of kids in the 1950s not to go somewhere usually made us want to go there even more….
One small upstairs window glowed yellow. On the porch sat a single jack-o’-lantern with a crooked smile.
Finally, six of us started walking toward it.
The closer we got, the quieter we became.
We climbed the porch steps.
Creeeeak.
Nobody wanted to knock.
Finally, Tommy raised his hand.
Knock. Knock. Knock.
Nothing happened.
Then we heard footsteps from inside.
Slow footsteps.
The doorknob turned.
The door opened.
Standing before us was the old witch down the block.
She wore a long black dress and a pointed black hat. Her gray hair hung around her face, and in one hand she carried an old broom.
None of us moved.
Then she leaned toward us.
“Well?” she said. “Aren’t you going to say trick or treat?”
“TRICK OR TREAT!” we yelled together.
The old witch smiled.
She reached behind the door and brought out an enormous bowl filled with candy bars, popcorn balls and caramel apples.
“Take two,” she told us.
Two!
Nobody else in the neighborhood was giving out two.
Suddenly the old witch didn’t seem frightening at all.
Before we left, she whispered, “Don’t tell the other children I’m nice. I have a reputation to keep.”
We laughed all the way back down the sidewalk.
By eight o’clock we were home. Mom had hot cider waiting in the kitchen while we dumped our Halloween treasure across the table and began trading candy.
But there was one thing none of us traded.
The treats from the old witch.
Years later, whenever Halloween came around, I would remember that little house down the block, the glowing jack-o’-lantern, the creaking porch and six frightened twelve-year-olds waiting for the door to open.
We eventually learned that the “old witch” was simply a kind elderly lady who loved Halloween and enjoyed giving the neighborhood children a good scare.
But on that chilly October night in 1957, we didn’t know that.

And for one wonderful Halloween night, the Old Witch Down the Block was real.



Leave a Reply